Cognitive Coherence Method™ (CCM)

The science behind Leap

How we measure an organization's incoherence, and how we reduce it.

Scientific engraving of a human brain seen in profile
Fig. 1Cognitive science studies how people represent, decide and act. The method takes its name from it.

The problem

Two organizations in one

Every organization has two versions of itself. One is written down: the strategy, the org chart, the values, the processes. The other happens every day, in what people decide, prioritize and do. We call the distance between them organizational incoherence.

Faced with its symptoms, organizations tend to communicate more, train more or reorganize. Each response acts on a single piece. Communication adds information for people who already had it, training builds skills the environment then keeps people from using, and reorganizing moves boxes around while habits stay the same.

Ostensive side

What is declared

The rule as it is written: the process, the value, the agreement.

The gap

Performative side

What is real

What people actually do in each concrete situation.

Fig. 2Every organizational routine has two sides (Feldman and Pentland, 2003). There is coherence when they match.

The strategy exists. Execution gets lost along the way, above all between areas.

84%
of managers say they can rely on their boss and their direct reports all or most of the time.
9%
say they can always rely on colleagues in other functions and units.

Source: Sull, Homkes and Sull, Harvard Business Review, 2015. Nearly 8,000 managers in more than 250 companies.

Incoherence is also cognitive

Each person acts on the mental model they hold of the strategy, the priorities and their own role. When systems send signals that contradict the message, people believe the systems. That is why a coherence diagnosis answers two questions.

  • How far apart are what is declared and what is real?
  • How much do people agree on what they see?

Two organizations with the same gap need different paths depending on whether people agree about it. That second question gives the method its name.

The explanation

Three pillars at three levels

A behavior shows up when a person is able to do it, the environment allows it and something moves them to do it (the COM-B model, Michie, van Stralen and West, 2011). The method's three pillars come from those conditions.

Performance depends on how well the pieces fit, and that fit plays out in the individual, the group and the organization (the Congruence Model, Nadler and Tushman, 1980). That is why each pillar is observed at three levels.

Systems

Does the environment make what the strategy asks for easy or hard?

Individual

Role, goals and feedback

Whether each person is clear on their role, whether their work connects to the strategy and whether they have the authority and resources they need.

Collective

Team design and coordination networks

Whether a team's design lets it work, and how work actually flows between areas.

Organizational

Organizational architecture and decision processes

The structure, the key processes and how important decisions get made.

Behaviors

What do people actually do, and what leads them to do it?

Individual

Each person's biases and habits

How each person thinks, decides and acts in context, and how they respond to change and to mistakes.

Collective

Real team dynamics

How teams collaborate, decide, debate and hold each other accountable in practice.

Organizational

Culture and routines

The unwritten rules, what gets rewarded or tolerated and how the strategy is carried out in fact.

Human capabilities

Are people able to do what is needed?

Individual

Leadership, motivation and energy

Cognitive, leadership and learning capabilities, and the conditions that sustain them.

Collective

The team's own capabilities

Solving complex problems, deciding well, coordinating under pressure and learning as a unit.

Organizational

The capacity to learn and change

Whether the organization can transform itself and sustain change without depending on specific people.

Fig. 3The CCM map. Coherence is how well the nine cells fit with each other and with the declared strategy.

Systems create the context. The context enables or blocks behaviors. Behaviors strengthen or erode human capabilities, and human capabilities determine which systems can work. That is why incoherence almost never lives in a single cell.

The destination

A high-performance organization

Coherence is the means. The end is an organization that achieves superior results and sustains them. To describe that destination, the CCM adopts André de Waal's HPO Framework.

De Waal reviewed 290 studies on high performance and tested the findings in 1,470 organizations across countries. He defines a high-performance organization as one that outperforms its peers for at least five years, and groups 35 characteristics into five factors.

  • Management quality

    Leaders who build trust, act with integrity and steer toward results.

    Built mostly by

    Human capabilitiesBehaviors
  • Openness and action orientation

    Open dialogue, knowledge sharing and agile decisions.

    Built mostly by

    BehaviorsSystems
  • Long-term orientation

    Lasting relationships with clients, employees and partners.

    Built mostly by

    Systems
  • Continuous improvement and renewal

    Simplifying, improving and innovating systematically.

    Built mostly by

    SystemsHuman capabilities
  • Workforce quality

    Diverse, flexible people committed to demanding results.

    Built mostly by

    Human capabilities

The link between factors and pillars is the CCM's own reading. The HPO Framework describes what characterizes high performance; the CCM provides how to get there.

Source: HPO Center

The principles

How change happens

The evidence lets us answer what makes an organization truly change. Six principles govern the design of every CCM intervention.

Context outweighs information

Interventions that change the structure of a decision outperform those that only add information or reminders. That is why we work on processes, defaults, team design and systems first.

Behaviors take hold through practice in real context

A new pattern forms through repetition in response to the same cues, immediate feedback and gradual consolidation. Knowledge is the starting point; practice in everyday work is what produces change.

The three pillars are worked on together

A redesign needs human capabilities to sustain it, and a leadership program needs systems that let people apply what they learned. Work on one pillar alone and the other two pull the organization back.

The three levels are worked on at once

An individual change needs a team that reinforces it, and a team change needs an organization that backs it. The biggest fracture tends to sit between areas, and no individual program fixes it alone.

Change is designed with the people who will sustain it

People commit to what they had autonomy and a voice in. Co-designing with leaders is itself a mechanism of change: it builds understanding, commitment and capability along the way.

Success is the client's autonomy

An intervention ends well when the organization keeps improving on its own. Change lasts when the practices that work become the shared rule.

One condition runs through all six: measure and take care. Every intervention is measured in its context and designed with ethical judgment, using the OECD BASIC framework on consent, privacy and fairness as a reference.

The method

Four stages, one cycle

The stages put everything above into practice. Discovery locates the incoherence on the map, Design decides what to move first, Execution installs the new patterns and Sustainability leaves the capacity to keep improving in the organization's hands.

  1. Discovery

    Indicative duration: 3 to 6 weeks

    Where is the incoherence and what produces it?

    Delivers
    A coherence diagnosis, a map of incoherence by pillar and level, prioritized intervention hypotheses and a work plan for Design.
    Closes when
    The leadership team validates the diagnosis and sets priorities.
  2. Design

    Indicative duration: 2 to 4 weeks

    What to change, in what order and through which mechanisms?

    Delivers
    An intervention architecture, an execution plan with owners, milestones and metrics, and a working agreement with the leadership team.
    Closes when
    The intervention architecture is approved.
  3. Execution

    Indicative duration: 4 to 12 months

    How do the new patterns take hold in real work?

    Delivers
    Documented progress by pillar and level, plan adjustments based on what comes up during implementation and periodic progress reports.
    Closes when
    The agreed metrics show stable adoption.
  4. Sustainability

    Indicative duration: 2 to 3 months

    How does progress continue without outside support?

    Delivers
    An internal tracking system up and running, an internal team equipped to sustain the change, a final coherence assessment compared with the starting point and recommendations for the next cycle.
    Closes when
    The second measurement confirms the progress.
Fig. 4Cognitive Coherence Method™ (CCM). Sustainability closes by repeating the initial measurement: the comparison shows the progress and becomes the starting point of the next cycle.

The starting point

Coherence Assessment

It is the starting point of every CCM process. It covers the Discovery and Design stages: it locates the incoherence gaps, finds what produces them and ends with an intervention architecture agreed with your leaders.

What it measures

The state of the three pillars at their three levels, and how aligned they are with each other and with the declared strategy. It locates the incoherence gaps and ranks them by priority.

How it is done

With a discovery plan shaped to each organization: surveys, in-depth interviews, a review of strategy, structure and process documents, and a coherence analysis across pillars and levels. Organizational network analysis and The Five Behaviors are optional modules.

What it delivers

A diagnostic report, a map of incoherence by pillar and level, a results session with the leadership team, the intervention architecture and an execution plan with owners, milestones and metrics.

The instrument: Coherence Index

It evaluates each of the map's nine cells with three indicators and sums them up in a coherence score from 0 to 100.

Alignment

How far apart are what is declared and what is real?

Consensus

Do people see the same thing?

Fit

Is the cell consistent with the others and with the strategy?

Core findings rest on more than one source. Participation is voluntary and informed, and results are reported in aggregate to protect confidentiality. The Coherence Index is in its first version: its items and thresholds still need validation with data from real organizations.

The free diagnostic is a first reading from one person's point of view. The Assessment confirms whether others see the same thing and what produces the gaps.

The limits

When the CCM is not the right tool

The method takes time, openness and commitment from leadership. In some situations another response works better, and we would rather say so before we start.

  • A survival crisis

    With an urgent cash, legal or reputational problem, the priority is to stabilize. The CCM makes sense afterwards.

  • A narrow problem with a known fix

    A specific process, tool or technical skill is better solved by a specialist.

  • Leadership looking to validate a decision already made

    The diagnosis shows data on the whole organization, including its leadership team. Without the will to look at it, the process loses its value.

  • No sponsorship

    Without backing from the top and real time from leaders, changes stall halfway.

  • Expecting results in weeks

    The first effects appear within six months, and the deepest ones take more than a year.

  • Very small organizations

    When everyone works in direct contact, a well-facilitated conversation does more than a formal diagnosis.

Technical manual

The full method, with its evidence and its limits

The Cognitive Coherence Method™ (CCM) technical manual is for anyone who evaluates, implements or oversees the method and wants to understand its full foundation: the research behind it, how it is applied and what still needs validating.

The public edition is a 36-page PDF, available in Spanish only. Leave your name, email and organization to download it.

Request the manual

By submitting you accept our Privacy policy.

Frequently asked questions

Questions about the method

What is the Cognitive Coherence Method™ (CCM)?

It is Leap's method for measuring and reducing organizational incoherence, the distance between what an organization declares and what happens day to day. It looks at three pillars (systems, behaviors and human capabilities) across three levels (individual, collective and organizational) and is applied in four stages.

What is organizational incoherence?

It is the distance between the written organization (strategy, org chart, values and processes) and the one that happens every day in what people decide, prioritize and do. When systems send signals that contradict the message, people believe the systems.

What scientific evidence is it based on?

It combines research on high-performance organizations with cognitive science. To describe the destination it adopts André de Waal's HPO Framework, built on 290 studies and tested in 1,470 organizations. Cognitive science explains why people act as they do and how that behavior changes.

What does the Coherence Index measure?

It measures how far apart the declared and the real are, and how much people agree on what they see, across the nine cells formed by the three pillars and the three levels. Its result is the coherence score.

What are the stages of the method?

There are four: Discovery (3 to 6 weeks), Design (2 to 4 weeks), Execution (4 to 12 months) and Sustainability (2 to 3 months). At the end the initial measurement is repeated to compare progress with the starting point.

When do results show?

The first effects appear within six months and the deepest ones take more than a year. Each intervention is measured in its context with metrics agreed during Design.

When is the CCM not the right tool?

When there is a survival crisis, a narrow problem with a known solution, leadership looking to validate a decision already made, no sponsorship, an expectation of results in weeks, or an organization so small that a well-facilitated conversation does more than a formal diagnosis.

Let's talk

Does it make sense to explore something together?

A conversation with no set agenda, to understand your reality.